Missed the exemption deadline on Oct 13th? What happens next →

News · November 6, 2026

The 57th Street Corridor: The Tax's Densest Square Mile

ZIP 10019 holds 975 condo and co-op units above the $1 million threshold—more than any other postal code in the city—and faces a combined exposure of $84.7 million if every unit proves non-primary.

aerial view photography of cityscape
Photo by Benjamín Gremler on Unsplash

The concentration

New York City's pied-à-terre surcharge, effective July 1 2026, falls most heavily on a single square mile. ZIP 10019—the corridor bounded roughly by Central Park South, Eighth Avenue, 59th Street and the Hudson—holds 975 condominium and cooperative units valued at $1 million or more, according to Conquest's analysis of DOF's July 2026 Supplemental Market Value Roll. That is more than any other postal code in the five boroughs.

If every one of those units turns out to be a non-primary residence, the combined surcharge for the 2026–27 fiscal year would reach $84.7 million. The median market value in the ZIP is $1.58 million and the average surcharge per unit is $86,862.

Most of those units are primary residences and will owe nothing. The figures represent exposure, not a forecast of what the city will collect. The density matters, though: 10019 accounts for roughly 4 percent of the city's 24,173 units above the threshold, and owners there face the tightest deadline pressure because a single building can hold dozens of potentially affected apartments.

How the surcharge works in 10019

The surcharge applies to condos and co-ops that are not the primary residence of the owner or an immediate family member and that carry a DOF market value of $1 million or more. Market value is the figure DOF publishes on the annual Notice of Property Value—not assessed value, which for Class 2 properties runs about 45 percent of market and is used only for the regular property tax.

The rate structure is flat, not marginal. Once market value clears $1 million, the applicable rate applies to the full market value. For the first three years—through June 30 2029—the rates are 4 percent on market value between $1 million and $3 million, 5.25 percent from $3 million to $5 million, and 6.5 percent at $5 million and above.

A $1.5 million condo therefore owes $60,000 if it is non-primary. A $3.2 million unit owes $168,000. A $6 million penthouse owes $390,000. The surcharge does not reduce if the owner claims a STAR exemption or an abatement; those apply only to the base property tax.

The buildings driving the count

The 10019 total is driven by a handful of high-rise towers built or converted in the last two decades. One57, 220 Central Park South, and the Time Warner Center each hold hundreds of units above the $1 million line, and each building's mix of full-time residents, occasional-use owners, and investor-held units will determine the actual tax roll.

DOF mailed non-primary-residence notices to properties it believes may be subject to the surcharge by August 30 2026. Owners had until October 13 2026 to file an exemption application establishing primary residence. That deadline has passed. Owners who missed it or who received a denial may appeal to the Tax Commission by March 1 2027.

The October 13 extension—DOF's third—came after the original August 21 and August 24 deadlines and a September 18 extension. The repeated delays reflected the volume of inquiries and the complexity of proving primary residence when an owner splits time between New York and another home.

Primary residence and the January 5 rule

Primary-residence status is determined as of January 5 of the year preceding the fiscal year in question. For the 2026–27 tax year, the relevant date was January 5 2026. An owner who moved into a 10019 condo in March 2026 and made it her primary residence will still owe the surcharge for 2026–27 because she was not living there on the January 5 snapshot.

The rule creates a trap for buyers who closed in early 2026 and assumed they would qualify for the exemption by living in the unit most of the year. DOF does not prorate the surcharge by days of occupancy. The unit either was the owner's primary residence on January 5 or it was not.

Immediate family use counts as primary residence. If the owner's spouse, child, sibling, parent, grandparent, or grandchild lived in the unit as a primary residence on January 5, the unit is exempt. A 12-month arm's-length lease to an unrelated natural person also exempts the unit, but short-term rentals and corporate leases do not.

The valuation question

Market value in 10019 has been volatile. Units that traded at $2 million in 2022 are now valued by DOF at $1.8 million, and units that sold for $4 million in 2021 are listed at $3.5 million. The surcharge is based on DOF's valuation, not the owner's purchase price or a broker's opinion.

Owners who believe DOF's market value is too high may challenge it through the Tax Commission. The deadline for a combined primary-residence and market-value appeal is March 1 2027 for Class 2 properties. If the owner first appeals the residency determination to DOF and receives a final denial, the owner has 30 days from the date of that notice or until March 1 2027, whichever is later, to file with the Tax Commission.

A successful market-value reduction can drop a unit below the $1 million threshold or into a lower rate band. A $1.05 million unit reduced to $990,000 owes nothing. A $3.1 million unit reduced to $2.9 million saves $162,750 in the first year alone.

The Phase 2 outlook

Beginning July 1 2028, the surcharge structure changes. Condos and co-ops will be revalued using a methodology closer to comparable sales, and the rate bands will shift to match the 1-3 family schedule: 0.8 percent on market value between $5 million and $15 million, 1.05 percent from $15 million to $25 million, and 1.3 percent above $25 million.

The $1 million threshold disappears. A $2 million condo that today would owe $80,000 will owe nothing under Phase 2. A $6 million unit that today owes $390,000 will owe $48,000. The change is a windfall for owners below $5 million and a modest reduction for those above it, but only if the unit remains non-primary.

The Phase 2 revaluation is not yet defined in detail. DOF has not published the comparable-sales formula or the appeals process that will apply. Owners planning around the 2028 shift should not assume today's market value will carry forward unchanged.

The arithmetic for one 10019 owner

Consider a 1,200-square-foot two-bedroom at 157 West 57th Street, market value $2.4 million. The owner lives in Greenwich and uses the apartment 40 nights a year. She did not file an exemption application by October 13 and has not appealed.

Her surcharge for 2026–27 is $96,000. Her regular property tax, after the condo abatement, is roughly $18,000. The combined bill is $114,000, or $9,500 a month. If she holds the unit through Phase 2, the surcharge drops to zero on July 1 2028 because the unit falls below the new $5 million threshold.

She has three options: sell before the January 1 2027 payment, appeal the market value and argue for a reduction below $1 million, or hold through Phase 2 and pay two years of surcharge. The decision turns on whether she believes the unit will appreciate enough in two years to offset $192,000 in surcharge payments.

What to watch

The first surcharge bills are due January 1 2027. DOF has not yet published the payment schedule or confirmed whether the surcharge will be collected quarterly, semiannually, or in a lump sum. The NYC Comptroller stated on November 2 2026 that billing could begin as early as November 2026, but no exact date has been established.

The March 1 2027 Tax Commission deadline will determine how many 10019 owners challenge their valuations. A wave of successful appeals could reduce the effective tax base and lower the city's first-year revenue below the Comptroller's $500 million projection.

Conquest's free DOF market-value and surcharge checker shows the market value DOF assigned to any address and calculates the surcharge under both Phase 1 and Phase 2 rates. Owners in 10019 and across the city can use it to confirm their exposure and model the Phase 2 savings before deciding whether to sell or hold.

Frequently asked questions

Is my $1.5 million apartment in 10019 subject to the pied-à-terre tax?

Your apartment is subject to the surcharge only if it was not your primary residence (or that of an immediate family member) on January 5, 2026, and if DOF's market value is $1 million or more. If it was non-primary on that date, the surcharge for 2026–27 is $60,000 (4 percent of $1.5 million market value).

How much is the pied-à-terre tax on a $3.2 million condo?

A $3.2 million condo that is non-primary owes $168,000 for the 2026–27 fiscal year under the 5.25 percent rate that applies to market values between $3 million and $5 million. The rate applies to the full market value, not just the amount above $3 million.

Does the pied-à-terre tax change in 2028?

Yes, beginning July 1, 2028, the threshold rises to $5 million and rates drop sharply: a $2 million unit that owes $80,000 today will owe nothing, and a $6 million unit will owe $48,000 instead of $390,000. Units below $5 million will be exempt under Phase 2.

Sources

Check My Address — Free